Method and apparatus for processing a modulated signal using an equalizer and a rake receiver

ABSTRACT

In a method for achieving higher S/N, one or more signals are received and processed to provide one or more streams of samples. In a first processing scheme, the sample stream(s) are equalized within an equalizer to generate symbol estimates, which may be subsequently processed (e.g., despread and decovered) to provide a first stream of recovered symbols. Each sample stream is filtered with a set of coefficients and may be scaled with a scaling factor. The scaled samples for all streams are then combined to generate the symbol estimates. The sample stream(s) may also be processed by a second processing scheme with one or more rake receivers to provide a second stream of recovered symbols. The signal quality for each processing scheme can be estimated and used to select either the first or second processing scheme.

CLAIM OF PRIORITY UNDER 35 U.S.C. § 120

The present Application for Patent is a Continuation and claims priority to patent application Ser. No. 09/624,319, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR PROCESSING A MODULATED SIGNAL USING AN EQUALIZER AND A RAKE RECEIVER,” filed Jul. 24, 2000, now allowed, and assigned to the assignee hereof and hereby expressly incorporated by reference herein.

BACKGROUND

1. Field

The present invention relates to data communication. More particularly, the present invention relates to a novel and improved method and apparatus for processing a received modulated signal using an equalizer and a rake receiver for improved performance.

2. Background

A modern day communication system is required to support a variety of applications. One such communication system is a code division multiple access (CDMA) system that supports voice and data communication between users over a terrestrial link. The use of CDMA techniques in a multiple access communication system is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,901,307, entitled “SPREAD SPECTRUM MULTIPLE ACCESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEM USING SATELLITE OR TERRESTRIAL REPEATERS,” and U.S. Pat. No. 5,103,459, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR GENERATING WAVEFORMS IN A CDMA CELLULAR TELEPHONE SYSTEM.” Another specific CDMA system is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 6,574,211, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR HIGH RATE PACKET DATA TRANSMISSION,” issued Jun. 3, 2003, (hereinafter, the HDR system). These patents are assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated herein by reference.

A CDMA system is typically designed to conform to one or more standards. Such standards include the “TIA/EIA/IS-95 Remote Station-Base Station Compatibility Standard for Dual-Mode Wideband Spread Spectrum Cellular System” (the IS-95 standard), the standard offered by a consortium named “3^(rd) Generation Partnership Project” (3GPP) and embodied in a set of documents including Document Nos. 3G TS 25.211, 3G TS 25.212, 3G TS 25.213, and 3G TS 25.214 (the W-CDMA standard), and the “TR-45.5 Physical Layer Standard for cdma2000Spread Spectrum Systems” (the CDMA-2000 standard). New CDMA standards are continually proposed and adopted for use. These CDMA standards are incorporated herein by reference.

A CDMA system typically employs a rake receiver to process a modulated signal that has been transmitted on the forward or reverse link. The rake receiver typically includes a searcher element and a number of finger processors. The searcher element searches for strong instances of the received signal (or multipaths). The finger processors are assigned to process the strongest multipaths to generate demodulated symbols for those multipaths. The rake receiver then combines the demodulated symbols from all assigned finger processors to generate recovered symbols that are estimates of the transmitted data. The rake receiver efficiently combines energy received via multiple signal paths.

The rake receiver provides an acceptable level of performance for CDMA systems operated at low signal-to-noise ratio (S/N). For CDMA systems designed to transmit data at high data rates, such as the HDR system, higher S/N is required. To achieve the higher S/N, the components that make up the noise term N need to be reduced. The noise term includes thermal noise (No), interference (Io) due to transmissions by other transmitting sources and transmissions for other users, and inter-symbol interference (ISI) that can come from multipath and distortion in the transmission channel. For CDMA systems designed to operate at low S/N, the ISI component is typically negligible compared to other noise components. However, for CDMA systems designed to operate at higher S/N, the other noise components (e.g., interference from other transmission sources) are typically reduced, and ISI becomes a non-negligible noise component that may have a large impact on the overall S/N.

As noted above, the rake receiver provides acceptable performance when the S/N of the received signal is low. The rake receiver can be used to combine energy from various multipaths, but generally does not remove the effects of ISI (e.g., from multipath and channel distortion). Thus, the rake receiver may not be capable of achieving the higher S/N required by CDMA systems operating at higher data rates.

As can be seen, techniques that can be used to process a received modulated signal to achieve higher S/N needed to support higher data rates are highly desirable.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention provides techniques that can achieve the higher S/N needed to support higher data rates. In accordance with the invention, a number of signal processing paths can be provided to process one or more signals (e.g., received via one or more antennas). One signal processing path includes an equalizer that attempts to reduce the ISI due to multipath and channel distortion. Another signal processing path can be implemented with one or more conventional rake receivers. Although the signal processing path that includes the equalizer typically provides better performance under certain operating conditions, the signal processing path having a better signal quality estimate can be selected to process the received signal(s).

An embodiment of the invention provides a method for processing one or more signals in a (spread spectrum) communication system. In accordance with the method, one or more signals are received (e.g., via one or more antennas) and processed to provide one or more streams of samples, which are then further processed by a first processing scheme to provide a first stream of recovered symbols. In the first processing scheme, the stream(s) of samples are equalized and combined within an equalizer to generate symbol estimates, which may subsequently be further processed (e.g., despread and decovered) to provide the first stream of recovered symbols. The stream(s) of samples may also be processed by a second processing scheme with one or more rake receivers to provide a second stream of recovered symbols. A signal quality associated with each processing scheme can be estimated and used to select either the first or second processing scheme.

In the first processing scheme, the sample stream(s) may be equalized prior to being combined. In this case, each stream of samples is filtered by a respective filter with a set of coefficients and may be scaled by a respective scaling factor. The scaled samples for all streams are then combined to generate the symbol estimates. Alternatively, the sample stream(s) may be combined prior to being equalized. In this case, each stream of samples can be scaled by a respective (complex) scaling factor. The scaled samples for all streams are then combined to generate summed samples that are further filtered with a set of coefficients to generate the symbol estimates.

Each filter within the equalizer can be implemented as a finite impulse response (FIR) filter, an infinite impulse response (IIR) filter, or some other filter structure. The filter coefficients and scaling factor(s) are typically adapted (i.e., trained) prior to being used, and may further be adapted during use (e.g., using a decision directed adaptation scheme).

Depending on the particular design of the equalizer, various adaptation schemes can be used. In one adaptation scheme, the filter coefficients are adapted separately and sequentially with respect to the scaling factor(s). In this adaptation scheme, the coefficient adaptation can be performed with the scaling factor(s) fixed, and the scaling factor adaptation can be performed with the coefficients fixed. The coefficient adaptation and scaling factor adaptation can be performed iteratively a number of times (e.g., over a particular sequence of expected symbols of known values). For the coefficient adaptation, the coefficients of each filter can be adapted based on (1) the filtered samples from the filter and the expected symbols or (2) the symbol estimates and the expected symbols. Similarly, the scaling factors can be adapted based on the symbol estimates and the expected symbols. Alternatively, in another adaptation scheme, the coefficients for all filters are adapted simultaneously based on the symbol estimates and the expected symbols.

For the above adaptation schemes, the adaptation can be performed using, for example, time division multiplexed (TDM) pilot reference, and in accordance with a least mean square (LMS) algorithm, a recursive least square (RLS) algorithm, a direct matrix inversion (DMI) algorithm, or some other adaptation algorithm. Prior to the adaptation, the coefficients of each filter can be initialized to a particular set of values (e.g., 0, . . . , 0, α*, 0, . . . , 0) and the scaling factor(s) can also be initialized. A large multipath for each signal being received and processed can be identified and the magnitude and phase of the multipath (α) can be used to initialize the coefficients and scaling factor associated with the signal. A large multipath for one of the signal(s) being received and processed can also be identified and a time offset corresponding to this multipath can be used for the coefficient and scaling factor adaptation (e.g., the time offset can be used to properly generate the expected values).

The signal quality associated with the first processing scheme can be estimated based on a mean square error (MSE) between the symbol estimates and the expected symbols. The coefficient and scaling factor adaptation can be implemented to minimize this MSE. The MSE can be translated to a signal-to-noise ratio (S/N). The MSE or SIN can then be used to select the data rate for the received signal(s).

Another embodiment of the invention provides a receiver unit operative to process one or more signals in a spread spectrum communication system. The receiver unit includes one or more pre-processors and a first signal processing path that comprises an equalizer and a post processor. Each pre-processor receives and processes a respective signal to provide a corresponding stream of samples. The equalizer receives, combines, and equalizes one or more streams of samples to generate symbol estimates. The post processor receives and may further process (e.g., despread and decover) the symbol estimates to provide a first stream of recovered symbols. The receiver unit may further include a second signal processing path and a controller. The second signal processing path can comprise one or more rake receivers used to process the sample stream(s) to generate a second stream of recovered symbols. The controller receives estimates of signal quality associated with the first and second signal processing paths and selects the first or second signal processing path based on the received signal quality estimates.

The post processor can include a PN despreader and a decover element. The PN despreader receives and despreads the symbol estimates with a PN sequence at a particular time offset to provide despread samples. The decover element decovers the despread samples with one or more channelization (e.g., Walsh) codes to provide the first stream of recovered symbols.

In one design, the equalizer includes one or more filters, one or more multipliers, and a summer. Each filter receives and filters a respective stream of samples with a set of coefficients to provide corresponding filtered samples. Each multiplier receives and scales the filtered samples from a respective filter with a respective scaling factor to provide scaled samples. The summer receives and sums the scaled samples from all multipliers to provide the symbol estimates.

In another design, the equalizer includes one or more multipliers, a summer, and a filter. Each multiplier receives and scales a respective stream of samples with a respective scaling factor to provide scaled samples. The summer receives and sums the scaled samples from all multipliers to provide summed samples. The filter receives and filters the summed samples with a set of coefficients to provide the symbol estimates.

In the above designs, the equalizer further includes a coefficient adjustment element that adapts the coefficients of each filter and the scaling factor(s) for the multiplier(s). Various adaptation schemes can be used, as described above. Depending on the selected adaptation scheme, the filter coefficients can be adapted based on either the filtered samples received from the filter or the symbol estimates. Also, the adaptation can be performed using the pilot reference and in accordance with the LMS, RLS, DMI, or some other algorithm.

The receiver unit can be used at a base station or a remote terminal in a spread spectrum (e.g., CDMA) communication system.

The invention further provides other methods and receiver units that implement various aspects and features of the invention, as described below.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The features, nature, and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent from the detailed description set forth below when taken in conjunction with the drawings in which like reference characters identify correspondingly throughout and wherein:

FIG. 1 is a simplified block diagram of an embodiment of the signal processing for a data transmission in a communication system;

FIG. 2A is a block diagram of an embodiment of a receiver within the communication system;

FIG. 2B is a block diagram of an embodiment of a digital processor within the receiver;

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of a receive data processor within the receiver unit in accordance with an embodiment of the invention;

FIGS. 4A and 4B are block diagrams of two embodiments of an equalizer that can be used to implement the equalizer shown in FIG. 3;

FIG. 5A is a diagram of an embodiment of a FIR filter, which can be used to implement each of the filters shown in FIGS. 4A and 4B;

FIG. 5B is a block diagram of an embodiment of a post processor used to process the symbol estimates from the equalizer to generate recovered symbols;

FIG. 6 is a diagram of a data frame format for a forward link transmission in the HDR CDMA system; and

FIG. 7 is a block diagram of an embodiment of a rake receiver.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

FIG. 1 is a simplified block diagram of an embodiment of the signal processing for a data transmission in a communication system 100. At a transmitter unit 110, data is sent, typically in packets, from a data source 112 to a transmit (TX) data processor 114 that formats, encodes, and processes the data to generate one or more analog signals. The analog signals are then provided to a transmitter (TMTR) 116 that amplifies, filters, quadrature modulates, and upconverts the received analog signals to generate a modulated signal suitable for transmission via one or more antennas 118 (only one is shown in FIG. 1) to one or more receiver units.

At a receiver unit 130, the transmitted signal is received by one or more antennas 132 a-132 k and provided to a receiver (RCVR) 134. Within receiver 134, each received signal is amplified, filtered, frequency downconverted, quadrature demodulated, and digitized to provide inphase (I) and quadrature (Q) samples. The samples may be digitally processed and then provided to a receive (RX) data processor 136 that further processes and decodes the samples to recover the transmitted data. The processing and decoding at receive data processor 136 are performed in a manner complementary to the processing and encoding performed at transmit data processor 114. The decoded data is then provided to a data sink 138.

The signal processing described above supports transmissions of traffic data, messaging, voice, video, and other types of communication in one direction. A bi-directional communication system supports two-way data transmission. The processing in FIG. 1 can represent the forward link processing in a CDMA system, in which case, transmitter unit 110 can represent a base station and receiver unit 130 can represent a remote terminal. The signal processing for the reverse link is not shown in FIG. 1 for simplicity.

FIG. 2A is a block diagram of an embodiment of receiver 134. In this embodiment, receiver unit 130 includes a number of antennas 132 a through 132 k. Each antenna 132 couples to a respective received signal processor (or pre-processor) 210 within receiver 134. Within each pre-processor 210, the received signal from antenna 132 is (low noise) amplified by an amplifier 222, filtered by a receive (RX) filter 224, frequency downconverted and quadrature demodulated by a frequency converter/demodulator 226, and digitized by one or more analog-to-digital converters (ADCs) 228 to provide ADC samples. The ADC samples are further processed by a digital processor 230 to generate complex I_(IN) and Q_(IN) samples that are then provided to receive data processor 136. Digital processor 230 is described in further detail below.

As shown in FIG. 2A, receiver unit 130 includes a number of antennas 132 a through 132 k that couple to a number of pre-processors 210 a through 210 k used to process the signals received via the antennas. Each combination of antenna 132 and pre-processor 210 forms part of a signal path used to process a particular received signal. The use of multiple antennas 132 in receiver unit 130 provides spatial diversity and may further suppress interference from other transmission sources, both of which can improve performance. However, receiver unit 130 can also be designed with a single signal path and this is within the scope of the invention.

FIG. 2A shows some of the functional elements that can be used to implement pre-processor 210. Generally, pre-processor 210 can include any combination of the functional elements shown in FIG. 2A, and the elements can also be arranged in any order to obtain the desired output. For example, multiple stages of amplifiers and filters are typically provided within pre-processor 210. Moreover, different functional elements than those shown in FIG. 2A may also be included within pre-processor 210, and this is also within the scope of the invention.

FIG. 2B is a block diagram of an embodiment of digital processor 230. Depending on the particular design of receiver unit 130, the received signal may be sampled by ADCs 228 at a particular sampling rate, f_(ADC), and the subsequent receive data processor 136 may operate on samples at another sample rate, f_(SAMP). For example, the received signal may be sampled at approximately two, four, or eight times the chip rate. Depending on the particular receiver design, the ADC sampling rate may or may not be synchronous with the chip rate. Receive data processor 136 is designed to operate on samples at a particular sample rate (e.g., the chip rate) that may be different than the ADC sampling rate. Digital processor 230 can be used to achieve the sample rate conversion. In certain designs, it may be advantageous to operate the subsequent equalizer within receive data processor 136 at a sample rate that is higher than the ADC sampling rate (e.g., f_(SAMP)=2f_(ADC)). Digital processor 230 can then be designed and operated to provide the upsampling.

In the embodiment shown in FIG. 2B, data processor 230 includes an upsampler 242, a finite impulse response (FIR) filter 244, and a downsampler 246, all coupled in series. Upsampler 242 receives and upsamples the ADC samples by a factor of P. The upsampling can be achieved by inserting (P-1) zero valued samples between each pair of successive ADC samples. FIR filter 244 then receives and filters the upsampled samples to remove images generated by the upsampling. FIR filter 244 may further perform (match) filtering on the received samples. The filtered samples are provided to decimator 246 and decimated by a factor of Q to generate the (complex) samples x_(i)(n) that are provided to receive data processor 136. The decimation can be achieved by simply discarding (Q-1) samples from every Q filtered samples.

Data processor 230 can also be implemented with a sample rate converter (especially if P and Q are not integers) or some other design, and this is within the scope of the invention. Also, data processor 230 can be designed to provide additional and/or different functions, and this is also within the scope of the invention.

In the IS-95 CDMA system, a receiver unit is designed to operate at a low signal-to-noise ratio (S/N), where S denotes the desired signal and N denotes the total noise. The total noise includes the thermal noise (No), the interference (Io) due to transmissions by other transmitting sources and transmissions to other receiver units, and inter-symbol interference (ISI). The ISI can be due to multipath or frequency distortion in the received signal due to the transmitter unit, the transmission channel, and the receiver unit. For the IS-95 CDMA system, the low S/N results from the concurrent transmissions of data for multiple users over the same system bandwidth. At the receiver unit, the desired signal is recovered from a highly degraded received signal through the use of spread spectrum processing whereby energy from a longer time period is accumulated to generate a signal having improved S/N.

The processing of a spread spectrum signal is conventionally performed using a rake receiver that searches for strong instances of the received signal (or multipaths), processes the strongest multipaths, and combines the results from the processed multipaths to generate recovered symbols that are more accurate estimates of the transmitted data. The design and operation of a rake receiver are described in further detail below. The rake receiver efficiently combines energy from multiple signal paths and attempts to optimize the S/N. However, the rake receiver is limited in its ability to correct for channel-induced distortions in the received signal because of the limited number of finger processors used to process the multipaths.

For CDMA systems designed to transmit at higher data rates, such as the HDR system, higher S/N is required to support the higher data rates. To achieve a higher S/N, on the forward link of the HDR system, data is transmitted to one user at any given moment. This eliminates the interference due to transmissions for other users. Moreover, the interference from other transmitting base stations may be reduced by operating the HDR system with a reuse factor greater than one and by using a directional antenna at the transmitter unit or the receiver unit, or both. To further improve S/N, ISI (which is typically negligible in the IS-95 CDMA system) may need to be reduced. The present invention provides techniques to reduce ISI due to multipath and channel distortion to achieve higher S/N.

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of receive data processor 136 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, receive data processor 136 includes two signal processing paths that can be operated in parallel to provide improved performance, especially at higher data rates. The first signal processing path includes an equalizer 310 coupled to a post processor 320, and the second signal processing path includes a rake receiver 330.

Within receive data processor 136, the streams of samples from pre-processors 210 are provided to each of equalizer 310 and rake receiver 330. Each stream of samples is generated from a respective received signal. Equalizer 310 performs equalization on the received streams of samples and provides symbol estimates to post processor 320. Depending on the processing performed at transmitter unit 110, post processor 320 may further process the symbol estimates to provide recovered symbols. In particular, if PN spreading and covering are performed at the transmitter unit, post processor 320 may be configured to perform despreading with a complex PN sequence and decovering with one or more channelization codes. Phase rotation (which is achieved via pilot demodulation for a rake receiver) is implicitly achieved by equalizer 310 after the filter coefficients have been adopted.

Rake receiver 330 may be configured to process one or more multipaths of each received signal to provide recovered symbols for that received signal. For each stream of samples, rake receiver 330 may be configured to perform PN despreading, decovering, and coherent demodulation for a number of multipaths. Rake receiver 330 then combines demodulated symbols for all multipaths of a received signal to generate recovered symbols for that received signal. Rake receiver 330 may further combine the recovered symbols for all received signals to provide the overall recovered symbols that are provided from the rake receiver.

The recovered symbols from post processor 320 and rake receiver 330 can be provided to a switch (SW) 340 that selects the recovered symbols from either post processor 320 or rake receiver 330 to provide to a de-interleaver 350. The selected recovered symbols are then reordered by de-interleaver 350 and subsequently decoded by a decoder 360. A controller 370 couples to, and manages the operation of equalizer 310, post processor 320, rake receiver 330, and switch 340.

In accordance with the invention, equalizer 310 can be used to provide equalization of the received signals to reduce the amount of ISI in the received signals. Each received signal is distorted by the characteristics of the transmitter unit, the transmission channel, and the receiver unit. Equalizer 310 can be operated to equalize the overall response for each received signal, thus reducing the amount of ISI. The lower ISI improves S/N and may support higher data rates.

FIG. 4A is a block diagram of an embodiment of an equalizer 310 a, which can be used to implement equalizer 310 in FIG. 3. As shown in FIG. 4A, the signal received on each antenna 132 is processed by a respective pre-processor 210 to provide a stream of samples, x_(i)(n). Within equalizer 310 a, the samples from pre-processors 210 a through 210 k are provided to filters 410 a through 410 k, respectively. Each filter 410 performs equalization of the received samples,x_(i)(n), based on a particular set of coefficients adapted for the received signal being processed by that filter. The (per antenna) symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n) from filters 410 a through 410 k are then provided to multipliers 412 a through 412 k, respectively, which also receive the scaling factors s₁ through S_(K), respectively. Each multiplier 412 scales the received symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) with the scaling factor s_(i) and provides scaled samples to a summer 414. The scaling factors can complex values, although real values may also be used especially after the coefficients within filters 410 have been adapted. Summer 414 receives and sums the scaled samples from multipliers 412 a through 412 k to generate the output (combined) symbol estimates ŷ(n).

A slicer 418 a can be provided within equalizer 310 a to receive and slice (i.e., quantize) the output symbol estimates ŷ(n) to generate sliced symbol estimates {tilde over (y)}(n). The sliced symbol estimates can be used to adapt the variables within equalizer 310 a (i.e., the coefficients within filters 410 and the scaling factors for multipliers 412) in a data directed adaptation scheme, as described below. The design of slicer 418 a can be dependent on the particular quadrature modulation scheme being supported, and more slicing levels can be provided for higher order modulation schemes (e.g., 16 QAM, 64 QAM, and so on). Although not shown in FIG. 4A for simplicity, one or more slicers can also be provided to slice the symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n) from filters 410 a through 410 k to generate sliced symbol estimates {tilde over (y)}₁(n) through {tilde over (y)}_(K)(n), respectively.

A coefficient adjustment element 420 a receives the symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n), the output symbol estimates ŷ(n), the sliced symbol estimates {tilde over (y)}(n), the actual (expected) symbols y(n), or a combination thereof. Coefficient adjustment element 420 a then adapts (i.e., trains or adjusts) the coefficients for filters 410 a through 410 k and the scaling factors for multipliers 412 a through 412 k based on the received symbol estimates and symbols. Coefficient adjustment element 420 a can be designed to implement the Least Mean Square (LMS) algorithm, the Recursive Least Square (RLS) algorithm, the direct matrix inversion (DMI) algorithm, some other algorithm, or a combination thereof. Coefficient adjustment element 420 a and the adaptation algorithms are described in further detail below.

FIG. 5A is a diagram of an embodiment of filter 410, which can be used to implement each of filters 410 a through 410 k in FIG. 4A. In this embodiment, filter 410 is implemented with a FIR filter. However, an infinite impulse response (IIR) filter or some other filter architecture can also be used and is within the scope of the invention.

Within filter 410, the received samples x_(i)(n) are provided to a number of delay elements 512 a through 512 m coupled in series. Each delay element 512 provides a particular amount of delay (e.g., one clock cycle of the received sample rate clock, 1/f_(SAMP)). The received samples x_(i)(n) and the outputs of delay elements 512 a through 512 m are provided to multipliers 514 a through 514 l, respectively. Each multiplier 514 also receives a coefficient c_(i,j), scales each received sample with the coefficient, and provides the scaled sample to a summer 516. Summer 516 sums the scaled samples from multipliers 514 a through 514 l and provides the symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n). The symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{{\hat{y}}_{i}(n)} = {\sum\limits_{j = {- M}}^{M}\quad{c_{i,j}^{*} \cdot {x_{i}\left( {n - j} \right)}}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(1)} \end{matrix}$ where the symbols (*) denotes a complex conjugate, and (2M+1) is the number of taps of filter 410.

Referring back to FIG. 4A, the output symbol estimates ŷ(n) from summer 414 can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{\hat{y}(n)} = {\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{K}\quad{s_{i}^{*} \cdot {{\hat{y}}_{i}(n)}}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(2)} \end{matrix}$ where K is the number of assigned signal processing paths within equalizer 310 a.

Each filter 410 in FIG. 4A provides a frequency response C_(i)(w) that attempts to equalize the overall frequency response G_(i)(w) experienced by the signal being processed by that filter. The overall frequency response G_(i)(w) of the signal includes the frequency response of the transmitter unit, the transmission channel, and the receiver unit (i.e., everything up to the filter). The coefficients of each filter 410 are “adapted” or “trained” such that reduced ISI can be achieved.

As shown in FIG. 4A, a number of signals may be received via a number of antennas 132 and processed by a corresponding number of pre-processors 210. Each pre-processor 210 provides a stream of samples to a respective filter 410. Each filter 410 can include a number of (2M+1) coefficients. Moreover, the symbol estimates from K filters 410 are scaled by K scaling factors and combined to generate the output symbol estimates ŷ(n). Thus, up to K·(2M+1)+K variables may be adjusted for equalizer 310 a. The K·(2M+1) coefficients of the K filters 410 and the K scaling factors can be adapted based on various adaptation schemes, some of which are described below.

In a first adaptation scheme, “time-domain” adaptation is performed for the coefficients of filters 410 followed by “space-domain” adaptation for the scaling factors. The time-domain adaptation adapts the coefficients of each filter 410 to provide equalization of the received signal being processed by that filter. The space-domain adaptation then adjusts the scaling factors associated with all assigned filters 410 to provide equalization of equalizer 310 a.

For the time-domain adaptation, filters 410 a through 410 k can be individually adapted based on their respective received samples and their equalized outputs. Prior to the first adaptation, the scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) can be initialized to a particular set of values (e.g., all 1/K). The scaling factors are typically normalized such that their sum total is equal to one, which can be expressed as: $\begin{matrix} {{\sum\limits_{l = 1}^{K}\quad{s_{l}(n)}} = {1.0.}} & {{Eq}\quad(3)} \end{matrix}$ The set of coefficients, c _(i)(n)=c_(i,−M)(n), . . . , c_(i,M)(n), for a particular filter 410 i can then be adapted based on the samples x_(i)(n) received by that filter and the samples y(n) expected to be received.

Initially, for each sample period n in which the coefficient adaptation is performed, a set of received samples, x _(i)(n)=x_(i)(n−M ), . . . , x_(i)(n+M), is filtered by filter 410 i with the set of coefficients c _(i)(n) to generate a symbol estimate ŷ_(i)(n), which can be expressed as: ŷ _(i)(n)= c _(i) ^(H)(n)· x _(i)(n),   Eq (4) where c _(i) ^(H)(n) is the Hermitian transposed (i.e., complex conjugated and transposed) set of coefficients. Equation (4) is written in vector form but is equivalent to equation (1) described above. The symbol estimate ŷ_(i)(n) is then provided to coefficient adjustment element 420 a.

Equalizer 310 a is typically adapted using known symbols prior to the first time the equalizer is used to process the received samples. For CDMA systems that transmit a pilot reference, the equalizer can be adapted using this pilot reference. If the pilot reference is transmitted using time division multiplexing (TDM), such as in the HDR system, the actual symbols y(n) at the output of equalizer 310 a are known during the pilot reference period and can be compared against the (per antenna) symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) or the output symbol estimates ŷ(n). The error between the actual symbols and the symbol estimates can be computed and used to adapt the equalizer. The generation of the actual symbol y(n) for the HDR system is described in further detail below.

Alternatively, if the pilot reference is transmitted using code division multiplexing (CDM), such as in the IS-95 system, the symbol estimates, ŷ_(i)(n) or ŷ(n), can be further processed to undo the CDM processing and generate recovered pilot symbols, {circumflex over (p)}_(i)(n) or {circumflex over (p)}(n), respectively, that can then be compared against the actual pilot symbols, p_(i)(n) or p(n), respectively. Again, the error between the actual pilot symbols and the recovered pilot symbols can be computed and used to adapt the equalizer. The adaptation of equalizer 310 a using a TDM pilot reference is described in detail below, and the adaptation of equalizer 310 a using a CDM pilot reference is described in a subsequent section.

For a sample period n in which the actual symbol y(n) is known, coefficient adjustment element 420 a can receive or generate the actual symbol y(n) for that sample period. An error e_(i)(n) between the symbol estimate ŷ_(i)(n) from filter 410 i and the actual symbol y(n) can then be computed for filter 410 i as: e _(i)(n)=y(n)−ŷ _(i)(n).   Eq (5) The error at any particular point in the processing path can be computed as the difference between the symbol estimate at that point and the expected symbol at that point.

Alternatively, for a sample period n in which the actual symbol y(n) is not known, an error e_(i)(n) between the symbol estimate ŷ_(i)(n) and the sliced symbol estimate {tilde over (y)}_(i)(n) can be computed for filter 410 i as: e _(i)(n)={tilde over (y)}_(i)(n)−ŷ _(i)(n).   Eq (6) The computed error e_(i)(n), using either equation (5) or (6), is then used to generate a new set of coefficients c _(i)(n+1) for the next sample period.

As noted above, various adaptation algorithms can be used to generate the new coefficients, some of which are described below.

For the LMS algorithm, the new coefficients c _(i)(n+1) can be computed as: c _(i)(n+1)= c _(i)(n)+ x _(i)(n)·μ·e* _(i)(n),   Eq (7) where μ is a unit-less adaptation constant.

For the RLS algorithm, the new coefficients c _(i)(n+1) can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{{{\underset{\_}{k}}_{i}(n)} = \frac{\lambda^{- 1}{P(n)}{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}(n)}}{1 + {\lambda^{- 1}{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}^{H}(n)}{P(n)}{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}(n)}}}},{{{\underset{\_}{c}}_{i}\left( {n + 1} \right)} = {{{\underset{\_}{c}}_{i}(n)} + {{{\underset{\_}{k}}_{i}(n)}{e_{i}^{*}(n)}}}},{and}}{{{P_{i}\left( {n + 1} \right)} = {{\lambda^{- 1}\left( {{I(n)} - {{{\underset{\_}{k}}_{i}(n)}{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}^{H}(n)}}} \right)}{P(n)}}},}} & {{Eq}\quad(8)} \end{matrix}$ where λ is a memory weighting factor (typically, 0.95<λ≦1.0), k _(i)(n) is a gain vector, I is the identity matrix (i.e., ones along the diagonal), and P is an inverse correlation matrix. Initially, P_(i)(0)=δ·I, where δ is a small positive number (e.g., 0.001).

For the DMI algorithm, the new coefficients c _(i)(n+1) can be computed with a training period of N_(SYM) symbols as follows: $\begin{matrix} {{{{{\hat{R}}_{i}(n)} = {\frac{1}{N_{SYM}}{\sum\limits_{m = {n - N_{SYM} + 1}}^{n}\quad{{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}(m)}{\underset{\_}{x}\quad}_{i}^{H}(m)}}}},\text{}{{{\underset{\_}{\hat{v}}}_{i}(n)} = {\frac{1}{N_{SYM}}{\sum\limits_{m = {n - N_{SYM} + 1}}^{n}\quad{{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{i}(m)}{y^{*}(m)}}}}},\quad{and}}{{{{\underset{\_}{c}}_{i}\left( {n + 1} \right)} = {\left\lbrack {{\hat{R}}_{i}(n)} \right\rbrack^{- 1}{{\underset{\_}{\hat{v}}}_{i}(n)}}},}} & {{Eq}\quad(9)} \end{matrix}$ where {circumflex over (R)}_(i)(n) is an estimate of the autocorrelation matrix of the received samples (i.e., the filter contents) and v _(i)(n) is a cross-correlation vector of the filter contents and the desired (expected) output. The estimates {circumflex over (R)}_(i)(n) and v _(i)(n) can be aggregated over multiple (possibly disjoint) training intervals. The matrix inversion of {circumflex over (R)}_(i)(n) in equation (9) may be performed only as often as necessary (e.g., once per slot in the HDR system based on the two disjoint pilot references, as shown in FIG. 6).

Each of the LMS, RLS, and DMI algorithm (directly or indirectly) attempts to minimize the mean square error (MSE), which may be expressed as: MSE=E{|y(n)−ŷ _(i)(n)|²},   Eq (10) where E{x} is the expected value of x. The LMS, RLS, DMI, and other adaptation algorithms are described in further detail by Simon Haykin in a book entitled “Adaptive Filter Theory,” 3^(rd) edition, Prentice Hall, 1996, which is incorporated herein by reference.

Once filters 410 a through 410 k are individually adapted in the manner described above, the space-domain adaptation can be performed to adapt the scaling factors. The space-domain adaptation can be achieved in a manner similar to that described above for the time-domain adaptation. Specifically, the coefficients of filters 410 a through 410 k are fixed, and the scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) are adjusted.

Initially, for each sample period n in which the scaling factors are adapted, each filter 410 i filters a set of received samples x _(i)(n) with its set of coefficients c _(i) to generate a symbol estimate ŷ_(i)(n). The symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n) from filters 410 a through 410 k are then provided to respective multipliers 412 a through 412 k and scaled with respective scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) to generate the output symbol estimate ŷ(n), which can be expressed as: $\begin{matrix} {{\hat{y}(n)} = {\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{K}\quad{{{\hat{y}}_{i}(n)} \cdot {{s_{i}^{*}(n)}.}}}} & {{Eq}\quad(11)} \end{matrix}$

The output symbol estimate ŷ(n) is then provided to coefficient adjustment element 420 a and used to generate an error e(n), which can be expressed as either: e(n)=y(n)−ŷ(n), or   Eq (12) e(n)={tilde over (y)}(n)−ŷ(n),   Eq (13) depending on whether the actual symbols are known (equation 12) or not known (equation 13). The computed error e(n) is then used to generate new scaling factors s₁(n+1) through s_(K)(n+1) (i.e., s(n+1)) using the LMS, RLS, DMI, or some other algorithm, in similar manner as that described above for the adaptation of the filter coefficients.

The time-domain and space-domain adaptations can be iterated a number of times (e.g., using the same or different pilot reference) to achieve the desired performance. The iterative adaptation can be performed as follows:

1) initialize the scaling factors to 1.0 (i.e., s₁=s₂= . . . =s_(K)=1/K);

2) initialize the coefficients of each of filters 410 a through 410 k (e.g., in a manner described below);

3) perform time-domain adaptation for the coefficients c _(i)(n) of each filter 410 i;

4) fix the coefficients c ₁ through c _(K) for filters 410 a through 410 k;

5) perform space-domain adaptation for the scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) with the filter coefficients fixed;

6) fix the scaling factors; and

7) repeat steps 3 through 5a number of times until the desired results are obtained.

Once the coefficients of filters 410 a through 410 k and the scaling factors are adapted, the symbol estimates ŷ(n) from equalizer 310 a represent good estimates of the transmitted samples.

After the initial adaptation, the equalizer can be (periodically) re-adapted when the known symbols are again received (e.g., during subsequent pilot reference periods). Alternatively or additionally, equalizer 310 a can be adapted using a decision directed adaptation scheme (e.g., during actual use, when the actual symbols are typically not known). Decision directed adaptation can be performed based on the error between the sliced symbol estimates (i.e., the expected signal level of the symbol estimates) and the symbol estimates (i.e., the actual level of the symbols as they are received).

The first adaptation scheme performs time-domain and space-domain adaptations separately and sequentially, which reduces the complexity of the required computations. For example, if each filter 410 includes (2M+1) coefficients, the time-domain adaptation can be achieved by performing operations on vectors of length 2M+1 and (possibly) matrices of dimension 2M+1 by 2M+1. And if K signal processing paths are operated in parallel to process K received signals, the space-domain adaptation can be achieved by performing operations on vectors of length K and (possibly) matrices of dimension K by K.

In a second adaptation scheme, the time-domain and space-domain adaptations are performed simultaneously for the coefficients and scaling factors within equalizer 310 a. In this embodiment, all filters 410 a through 410 k are operated in parallel to filter their respective streams of samples x₁(n) through X_(K)(n). The symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n) from filters 410 a through 410 k can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{{\hat{y}}_{1}(n)} = {{{\underset{\_}{c}}_{1}^{H}(n)} \cdot {{\underset{\_}{x}}_{1}(n)}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(14)} \\ \vdots & \quad \\ {{{\hat{y}}_{K}(n)} = {{{\underset{\_}{c}}_{K}^{H}(n)} \cdot {{{\underset{\_}{x}}_{K}(n)}.}}} & \quad \end{matrix}$

The symbol estimates ŷ₁(n) through ŷ_(K)(n) are then provided to multipliers 412 a through 412 k, respectively, scaled by the respective scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n), and combined to generate the output symbol estimate ŷ(n), which can be computed as shown in equation (11).

An error e(n) between the symbol estimate ŷ(n) and the actual symbol y(n) or the sliced symbol estimate {tilde over (y)}(n) is computed, as shown in equation (12) or (13), respectively. The error e(n) is then used to simultaneously adapt the K sets of filter coefficients c ₁(n) through c _(K)(n) (with the K scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) fixed). The K set of filter coefficients can be concatenated into one vector of length K·(2M+1), which is adjusted by the error e(n). In this embodiment, up to K·(2M+1) variables are adapted simultaneously.

In the second adaptation scheme, for a particular set of scaling factors, the filter coefficients are adapted simultaneously by performing operations on vectors of length K·(2M+1) and (possibly) matrices of dimension K·(2M+1) by K·(2M+1). The required computations can be more complicated than those performed for the first adaptation scheme described above. However, improved performance may be achieved since all coefficients can be jointly considered to equalize the received signals such that the output symbol estimates ŷ(n) are good estimates of the actual symbol y(n). For example, the coefficients of the filter used for antenna 1 can depend on the signal(s) received via other antenna(s).

The adaptation of the filter coefficients and the scaling factors can be achieved with the assistance of rake receiver 330. In a typical design, rake receiver 330 includes a searcher element and a number of finger processors. The searcher element processes the samples for a particular received signal at various time offsets, possibly as directed by controller 370, and searches for the strongest multipaths. For a CDMA system, the searcher element typically performs a correlation of the received samples with a (complex) PN sequence that was used to spread the samples at the transmitter unit. The searcher element can be designed to perform the correlation at a specific time offset or at multiple time offsets. Each time offset corresponds to a specific delay of the PN sequence relative to an absolute (zero delay) PN sequence. The searcher element may also be designed to provide a (complex) correlation result for each time offset being examined or just correlation results that exceed a particular threshold. The searcher element or controller 370 can be designed to maintain a list of correlation results and their corresponding time offsets for each received signal.

Based on the list of correlation results for all received signals, controller 370 can identify the strongest multipath (e.g., the multipath having the largest magnitude or energy). The functions performed by the searcher element and finger processors are described in further detail below.

In an embodiment, the initial values for the filter coefficients can be set based on the correlation results from rake receiver 330. For each received signal, rake receiver 330 can be operated to search for the strongest multipaths. The magnitude of the correlation results for the strongest multipaths for each received signal can be ranked. The index Ji corresponding to the strongest multipath for a particular received signal can be determined as: $\begin{matrix} {{Ji} = {\arg{\left\{ {\max\limits_{j}{\alpha_{i,j}}} \right\}.}}} & {{Eq}\quad(15)} \end{matrix}$ The strongest multipath for the particular received signal can then be determined as: $\begin{matrix} {{{\alpha_{Ji}} = {\max\limits_{j}{\alpha_{i,j}}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(16)} \end{matrix}$ where |α_(i,j)| is the magnitude of the j^(th) multipath of the i^(th) received signal and |α_(Ji)| is the magnitude of the strongest multipath for the i^(th) received signal. Similarly, the strongest multipaths for all received signals can be ranked and the strongest multipath among these can be identified as follows: $\begin{matrix} {{{\alpha_{I}} = {\max\limits_{i}{\alpha_{Ji}}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(17)} \end{matrix}$ where |α₁| is the magnitude of the strongest multipath for all received signals.

Once the strongest multipath for all received signals is determined, the time offset corresponding to this multipath can be identified. The coefficient c_(i,0)(n) for each filter 410 can then be initialized to one of the following: (1) a value related to a “finger value,” which is indicative of the received signal quality of the strongest multipath (e.g., c_(i,0)(n)=γ α_(Ji)*, where γ is a constant that may be dependent on the noise variance), (2) a value of one (1.0), or some other value. The remaining coefficients can each be initialized to zero (i.e., c_(i,−M)(n)= . . . =c_(i,−1)(n)=c_(i,1)(n)= . . . =c_(i,M)(n)=0.0). The time offset, τ_(Ji), corresponding to the strongest multipath, α_(Ji), can be separated into a “coarse” portion and a “fine” portion. The coarse portion can be used as a coarse adjustment to properly generate the actual symbols y(n) used to adapt the coefficients and scaling factors, as described below. The fine portion can be used as a fine adjustment to specify the time epic of the received samples x_(i)(n). Specifically, the fine portion can be used by digital processor 230 to adjust the timing of the resampling clock, which enables digital processor 230 to generate received samples x_(i)(n) aligned (in time) to the time offset. The time offset for the generation of the actual symbols y(n) also takes into account the number of taps of each filter 410 and the initial values of the coefficients.

The scaling factors can also be initialized with the assistance of rake receiver 330. For example, each of the scaling factors can be initialized to a value that is related to the magnitude of the strongest multipath of the received signal being scaled with that scaling factor. Thus, the scaling factors s₁(n) through s_(K)(n) can be set to values related to α_(J1) through α_(JK), respectively. Alternatively, the scaling factors can each be set to a particular value (e.g., 1/K) prior to the adaptation. Other methods to initialize the coefficients and scaling factors can also be used and are within the scope of the invention.

FIG. 4B is a block diagram of an embodiment of another equalizer 310 b, which can also be used to implement equalizer 310 in FIG. 3. Unlike equalizer 310 a in FIG. 4A, which performs equalization followed by spatial-domain combination, equalizer 310 b in FIG. 4B performs spatial-domain combination followed by equalization. The spatial-domain combination can be viewed as achieving beam forming with an array of K antennas 132. The architecture of equalizer 310 b is simpler than the architecture of equalizer 310 a and has a dimensionality that is approximately a factor of K less complex (i.e., equalizer 310 b has (2M+1)+K variables versus K·(2M+1)+K variables for equalizer 310 a). Equalizer 310 b can provide good estimates for certain operating conditions (e.g., if the scattering is not too great and if the antennas have approximately similar frequency response with some phase shifts).

As shown in FIG. 4B, the signal received on each antenna 132 is processed by a respective pre-processor 210 to provide a stream of samples, x_(i)(n). Within equalizer 310 b, the sample streams x₁(n) through X_(K)(n) from pre-processors 210 a through 210 k are provided to multipliers 422 a through 422 k, respectively, which also receive the respective scaling factors s₁ through s_(K). Each multiplier 422 scales the received samples x_(i)(n) with the scaling factor s_(i) and provides scaled samples to a summer 424. The scaling factors for multipliers 422 are typically complex values that allow for a complex combination of the signals received via multiple antennas 132. Summer 424 receives and sums the scaled samples from multipliers 422 a through 422 k to generate spatially combined samples x(n), which are then provided to a filter 410 x.

Filter 410 x performs equalization on the samples x(n) based on a particular set of coefficients. The symbol estimates ŷ(n) from filter 410 x are provided as the output of equalizer 310 b and are also provided to a coefficient adjustment element 420 b. Filter 410 x can be implemented with filter 410 shown in FIG. 5A. Similar to that described above for equalizer 310 a, a slicer 418 b can be provided within equalizer 310 b to receive and slice the symbol estimates ŷ(n) to generate sliced symbol estimates {tilde over (y)}(n).

Coefficient adjustment element 420 b also receives the actual symbols y(n), the symbol estimates ŷ(n), and the sliced symbol estimates {tilde over (y)}(n), or a combination thereof. Coefficient adjustment element 420 b then adapts the coefficients of filter 410 x and the scaling factors s₁ through s_(K) based on the received symbol estimates and symbols. Coefficient adjustment element 420 b can also be designed to implement the LMS, RLS, DMI, or some other algorithm, or a combination thereof. Coefficient adjustment element 420 b can be implemented similar to coefficient adjustment element 420 a in FIG. 4A.

The adaptation of the scaling factors and the coefficients within equalizer 310 b can be achieved using adaptation schemes similar to those described above for equalizer 310 a.

In the first adaptation scheme, time-domain adaptation is performed first followed by space-domain adaptation. To perform the time-domain adaptation, the scaling factors are initially set to a particular set of values, and the filter coefficients are then adapted. The initial values for the scaling factors may be determined, for example, using direction of arrival (DOA) estimation, which is known in radar theory and described by S. Haykin and A. Steinhardt, in a book entitled “Adaptive Radar Detection and Estimation,” John Wiley and Sons, Jun. 1992. Alternatively, the scaling factors may each be initialized, for example, to 1/K. With the scaling factors fixed, the filter coefficients can then be adapted using the LMS, RLS, DMI, or some other algorithm, similar to that described above.

Once the first iteration of the time-domain adaptation is completed, the coefficients can be fixed and the space-domain adaptation can be performed (e.g., over the same pilot reference or a different pilot reference). To perform the space-domain adaptation, the symbol estimates ŷ(n) are computed and used to adapt the scaling factors, again using the LMS, RLS, DMI, or some other algorithm, similar to that described above. The time-domain and space-domain adaptations may be iterated a number of times to achieve the desired results. Similar to that described above for equalizer 310 a, rake receiver 330 can be used to initially set the coefficients for filter 410 x and the scaling factors. For example, rake receiver 330 can be operated to search for the strongest multipaths for each received signal being processed. The strongest multipath for all received signals can be identified, based on equation (17). The coefficients for filter 410 x can be initialized based on the magnitude of the strongest multipath. The time offset corresponding to this multipath can be used to properly generate the actual symbols y(n) used for the adaptation.

Also, the strongest multipath for each received signal can be used to initially set the corresponding scaling factor. For example, the initial value for the scaling factor s₁ can be set based on the magnitude of the strongest multipath for the signal received via antenna 132 a, the initial value for the scaling factor s₂ can be set based on the magnitude of the strongest multipath for the signal received via antenna 132 b, and so on. The initial values for the scaling factors can also be set based on finger values that are indicative of the received signal quality (S/N).

For some CDMA systems, such as the HDR system, a pilot reference is time division multiplexed (TDM) with other data and transmitted from a base station to the remote terminals. For these CDMA systems, the filter coefficients and scaling factors can be adapted using the transmitted pilot reference. Thereafter, the coefficients and scaling factors are fixed and used to process data that is transmitted in the time periods between the pilot references.

FIG. 6 is a diagram of a data frame format for a forward link transmission in the HDR CDMA system. On the forward link, traffic data, pilot reference, and signaling data are time division multiplexed in a frame and transmitted from a base station to a remote terminal. Each frame covers a time unit referred to as a slot (e.g., 1.67 msec for a particular HDR design). Each slot includes traffic data fields 602 a, 602 b, and 602 c, pilot reference fields 604 a and 604 b, and signaling data (OH) fields 606 a and 606 b. Traffic data fields 602 and pilot reference fields 604 are used to send traffic data and pilot reference, respectively. Signaling data fields 606 are used to send signaling information such as, for example, forward link activity (FAC) indicators, reverse link busy indicators, reverse link power control commands, and so on. The FAC indicators indicate whether the base station has traffic data to send in a particular number of slots in the future. The reverse link busy indicators indicate whether the reverse link capacity limit of the base station has been reached. And the power control commands direct the transmitting remote terminals to increase or decrease their transmit power.

In accordance with the HDR CDMA system, prior to transmission, the traffic data is covered with Walsh codes corresponding to the channels to be used for the data transmission, and the power control data for each remote terminal is covered with the Walsh code assigned to the remote terminal. The pilot reference, covered traffic data, and power control data are then spread with a complex PN spreading sequence generated by multiplying the short IPN and QPN spreading sequences assigned to the particular transmitting base station with the long PN sequence assigned to the recipient remote terminal. At the highest date rates, the bit rate may match or exceed the chip rate of the PN spreading sequence and the Walsh codes, and no direct sequence spreading of the data is achieved. The data frame format and the processing of the forward link transmission for the HDR system is described in further detail in the aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 6,574,211.

For some CDMA systems, such as the IS-95 CDMA system, a pilot reference is code division multiplexed (CDM) with other data and transmitted from a base station to the remote terminals. For these CDMA systems, the filter coefficients and scaling factors can be adapted using the transmitted CDM pilot reference. However, since the pilot reference is code division multiplexed with other data, additional processing is performed on the per antenna symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) or the output symbol estimates ŷ(n) to extract the transmitted pilot reference.

For the IS-95 CDMA system, the pilot reference (an all ones sequence) is covered with a 64-chip all zeros Walsh sequence, combined with other covered data, and spread with the PN sequence. The transmitted CDM pilot reference can be recovered by processing the output symbol estimates ŷ(n) in a complementary manner. Referring to FIG. 5B, which is described in greater detail below, within post processor 320, the symbol estimates ŷ(n) are despread with the PN sequence, decovered with the pilot Walsh sequence, and accumulated over the (64-chip) pilot symbol period to generate recovered pilot symbols {circumflex over (p)}(n). The decovering removes the data on the other traffic channels, which have been covered with Walsh sequences that are orthogonal to the pilot Walsh sequence.

The error e(n) between the recovered pilot symbols {circumflex over (p)}(n) and the actual (expected) pilot symbol p(n) can then be computed as: e(n)=p(n)−{circumflex over (p)}(n).   Eq (18) The error e(n) can then be used to adapt the filter coefficients and scaling factors using any combination of adaptation scheme and adaptation algorithm (e.g., LMS, RLS, or DMI) described above. For equalizer 310 a in FIG. 4A, the adaptation can also be performed using the per antenna symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) from each filter 410. The symbol estimates ŷ_(i)(n) can be processed by post processor 320 in the manner described above to generate recovered pilot symbols {circumflex over (p)}_(i)(n). The error e_(i)(n) between the recovered pilot symbols {circumflex over (p)}_(i)(n) and the expected pilot symbol p_(i)(n) can then be computed as: e _(i)(n)=p _(i)(n)−{circumflex over (p)} _(i)(n).   Eq (19) Generally, an error between the recovered symbols (e.g., ŷ(n) or {circumflex over (p)}(n)) and the expected symbol (e.g., y(n) or p(n)) can be computed at any particular point in the receiver unit. Proper processing is performed such that “equivalent” or “like-kind” symbols are being compared.

For CDMA systems that transmit a CDM pilot reference, an error e(n) may be computed for each pilot symbol period (e.g., every 64 chips for the IS-95 CDMA system). If the CDM pilot reference is transmitted continuously, such as for the IS-95 CDMA system, the adaptation can also be performed in a continuous manner, albeit at a lower pilot symbol rate. For CDMA systems that transmit a TDM pilot reference, an error may be computed for each chip period. However, the adaptation using the TDM pilot reference is typically only performed during the pilot reference period.

As noted above, information from the rake receiver can be used to (1) initialize the filter coefficients prior to the first adaptation, (2) properly generate the expected symbols, y(n) or p(n), and (3) specify the time epic of the received samples x_(i)(n), as described above. For equalizer 310 a in FIG. 4A, the center coefficient c_(i,0)(n) of each filter 410 can be initialized to the finger value (e.g., c_(i,0)(n)=γα_(Ji)*) of the strongest multipath of the signal being processed by that filter. The time offset τ_(Ji) of the strongest multipath can be used to generate the expected symbols y(n) or the expected pilot symbols p(n), and to generate received samples x_(i)(n) that are aligned in time to the time offset. The expected symbols y(n) and p(n) are also generated by taking into account the delay associated with the processing elements up to the point where the error is computed. For example, for a particular time offset, τ_(Ji), the expected pilot symbols p(n) would be generated with a delay relative to expected symbols y(n), to account for the delay of post processor 320.

The filter coefficients and scaling factors can also be adapted using the received data. The received samples can be processed, decoded, and CRC checked to determine whether a data packet was received without error. A correctly received data packet can then be re-encoded and re-processed in a manner similar to that performed at the transmitter unit. The re-generated symbols can then be compared against the recovered symbols (e.g., ŷ(n)), and the error between these can be used to adapt the filter coefficients and scaling factors. The recovered symbols are appropriately buffered to account for the decoding, re-encoding, and re-processing delays.

FIG. 7 is a block diagram of an embodiment of rake receiver 330. Due to multipath and other phenomena, a transmitted signal may reach a receiver unit via multiple signal paths. For improved performance, the rake receiver is designed with the capability to process multiple (and strongest) instances of the received signal (or multipaths). For a conventional rake receiver design, a number of finger processors 710 are provided to process a number of multipaths. Each finger processor 710 comprises a finger of the rake receiver and can be assigned to process a particular multipath.

As shown in FIG. 7, the received I_(IN) and Q_(IN) samples from a particular pre-processor 210 are provided to a number of finger processors 710 a through 7101. Within each assigned finger processor 710, the received I_(IN) and Q_(IN) samples are provided to a PN despreader 720, which also receives a complex PN sequence, PNI and PNQ. The complex PN sequence is generated in accordance with the particular design of the CDMA system being implemented and, for the HDR system, is generated by multiplying the short IPN and QPN sequences with the long PN sequence by multipliers 738 a and 738 b. The short IPN and QPN sequences are used to spread the data at the transmitting base station, and the long PN sequence is assigned to the recipient receiver unit and used to scramble the data. The PNI and PNQ sequences are generated with a time offset corresponding to the particular multipath being processed by that finger processor.

PN despreader 720 performs a complex multiply of the complex I_(IN) and Q_(IN) samples with the complex PN sequence and provides complex despread I_(DES) and Q_(DES) samples to decover elements 722 and 732. Decover element 722 decovers the despread samples with one or more channelization codes (e.g., Walsh codes) that were used to cover the data and generates complex decovered samples. The decovered samples are then provided to a symbol accumulator 724 that accumulates the samples over the length of the channelization codes to generate decovered symbols. The decovered symbols are then provided to a pilot demodulator 726.

For the HDR system, a pilot reference is transmitted during a portion of the forward link transmission. Thus, decover element 732 decovers the despread samples with the particular channelization code (e.g., a Walsh code 0 for the HDR system) that was used to cover the pilot reference at the base station. The decovered pilot samples are then provided to an accumulator 734 and accumulated over a particular time interval to generate pilot symbols. The accumulation time interval can be the duration of the pilot channelization code, an entire pilot reference period, or some other time interval. The pilot symbols are then provided to a pilot filter 736 and used to generate pilot estimates that are provided to pilot demodulator 726. The pilot estimates are estimated or predicted pilot symbols for the time period when data is present.

Pilot demodulator 726 performs coherent demodulation of the decovered symbols from symbol accumulator 724 with the pilot estimates from pilot filter 736 and provides demodulated symbols to a symbol combiner 740. Coherent demodulation can be achieved by performing a dot product and a cross product of the decovered symbols with the pilot estimates. The dot and cross products effectively perform a phase demodulation of the data and further scale the resultant output by the relative strength of the recovered pilot. The scaling with the pilots effectively weighs the contributions from different multipaths in accordance with the quality of the multipaths for efficient combining. The dot and cross products thus perform the dual role of phase projection and signal weighting that are characteristics of a coherent rake receiver.

Symbol combiner 740 receives and coherently combines the demodulated symbols from all assigned finger processors 710 to provide recovered symbols for a particular received signal being processed by the rake receiver. The recovered symbols for all received signals may then be combined, as described below, to generate overall recovered symbols that are then provided to the subsequent processing element.

Searcher element 712 can be designed to include a PN despreader, a PN generator, and a signal quality measurement element. The PN generator generates the complex PN sequence at various time offsets, possibly as directed by controller 370, which are used in the search for the strongest multipaths. For each time offset to be searched, the PN despreader receives and despreads the I_(IN) and Q_(IN) samples with the complex PN sequence at the particular time offset to provide despread samples. The signal quality of the despread samples is then estimated. This can be achieved by computing the energy of each despread sample (i.e., I_(DES) ²+Q_(DES) ²) and accumulating the energy over a particular time period (e.g., the pilot reference period). Searcher element performs the search at numerous time offsets, and the multipaths having the highest signal quality measurements are selected. The available finger processors 710 are then assigned to process these multipaths.

The design and operation of a rake receiver for a CDMA system is described in further detail in U.S. Pat. No. 5,764,687, entitled “MOBILE DEMODULATOR ARCHITECTURE FOR A SPREAD SPECTRUM MULTIPLE ACCESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEM,” and U.S. Pat. No. 5,490,165, entitled “DEMODULATION ELEMENT ASSIGNMENT IN A SYSTEM CAPABLE OF RECEIVING MULTIPLE SIGNALS,” both assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated herein by reference.

In the embodiment shown in FIG. 2A, a number of forward link signals are received by antennas 132 a through 132 k and processed by pre-processors 210 a through 210 k, respectively, to generate sample streams x₁(n) through x_(K)(n). Thus, a number of rake receivers can be provided to process the K sample streams. A combiner may then be used to combine the recovered symbols from all received signals being processed. Alternatively, one or more rake receivers can be time division multiplexed to process the K sample streams. In this TDM rake receiver architecture, the samples from the K streams can be temporarily stored to a buffer and later retrieved and processed by the rake receiver.

For each received signal, rake receiver 330 can be operated to process up to L multipaths, where L represents the number of available finger processors 710. Each of the L multipaths corresponds to a particular time offset that is identified with the assistance of searcher element 712. Controller 370 or searcher element 712 can be designed to maintain a list of the magnitude of the strongest multipath (α_(Ji)) and its corresponding time offset (τ_(i)) for each of the K received signals being processed. These magnitudes and time offsets can be used to initialize the coefficients and scaling factors of equalizer 310, as described above. In one implementation, the magnitude of each multipath of interest can be computed as the square root of the accumulated energy value divided by the number of samples (N) used in the accumulation.

FIG. 5B is a block diagram of an embodiment of post processor 320 used to process the symbol estimates ŷ(n) generated from the received signals. Post processor 320 is operated to undo the PN spreading and covering that may have been performed at the transmitter unit. For example, prior to transmission, the HDR system performs PN spreading and covering of the data at lower data rates. At the higher data rates (matching or exceeding the chip rate), the PN spreading and covering may result in symbol inversion (i.e., changes in polarity) but no direct sequence spreading. Thus, post processor 320 can be operated to perform PN despreading and decovering at the lower data rates and symbol inversions at the higher data rates. Generally, post processor 320 is designed to perform functions that are complementary to those performed at the transmitter unit.

Within post processor 320, the symbol estimates are provided to a PN despreader 520, which also receives a complex PN sequence having the same time offset as that used to adapt the filter coefficients. PN despreader 520 despreads the symbol estimates with the complex PN sequence and provides the despread samples to a decover element 522. Decover element 522 then decovers the samples with one or more channelization codes used to cover the data at the base station. The decovered samples for each channel are then accumulated over the length of the channelization codes by a symbol accumulator 524 to generate recovered symbols that are then provided to the subsequent processing element.

Equalizer 310, post processor 320, and rake receiver 330 can be time division multiplexed to process samples of all received signals using a single set of processing elements. Also, some of the elements within post processor 320 are similar with those within rake receiver 330. Thus, post processor 320 and rake receiver 330 can be designed and operated such that at least some of the common functions can be performed by a shared set of processing elements.

During the adaptation period for filters 410 shown in FIGS. 4A and 4B, the actual symbol y(n) can be generated based on the time offset of the strongest multipath for all received signals. For the HDR system, the pilot reference is an all-ones sequence and the channelization code used to cover the pilot reference is Walsh code 0 (i.e., the all-zeros sequence). The pilot reference is then despread with the complex PN sequence. Thus, the transmitted pilot reference is equal to the complex PN sequence for the time duration in which the pilot reference is transmitted.

At the receiver unit, the actual symbol y(n) during the pilot reference period can be generated as the complex PN sequence at the time offset corresponding the strongest multipath of all received signals (i.e., y(n)=PNI(n)+jPNQ(n).

Referring back to FIG. 3, receive data processor 136 includes two signal processing paths that can be operated to process the received signals. The first signal processing path includes equalizer 310 and post processor 320, and the second signal processing path includes rake receiver 330. In an embodiment, the two signal processing paths can be operated in parallel (e.g., during the adaptation period) and a signal quality estimate can be computed for each of the signal processing paths. The signal processing path that provides the better signal quality can then be selected to process the received signals.

For a conventional rake receiver, the received signal quality can be estimated by computing the signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio. For CDMA systems that transmit TDM pilot reference, the S/N can be computed during the pilot reference period when the received signal is known. A signal quality estimate can be generated for each assigned finger processor. The estimates for all assigned finger processors can then be weighted and combined to generate an overall S/N, which can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{S\text{/}N_{RAKE}} = \frac{\left( {\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{K}\quad{\beta_{i} \cdot \sqrt{{Es}_{i}}}} \right)^{2}}{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{K}\quad{\beta_{i}^{2} \cdot {Nt}_{i}}}} & {{Eq}\quad(20)} \end{matrix}$ where β is the weighting factors used by the rake receiver to combine the demodulated symbols from the assigned finger processors to provide the recovered symbols that are improved estimates of the transmitted data, Es is the energy-per-symbol for the desired signal (e.g., the pilot), and Nt is the total noise on the received signal being processed by the finger processor. Nt typically includes thermal noise, interference from other transmitting base stations, interference from other multipaths from the same base station, and other components. The energy-per-symbol can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{Es} = {\frac{1}{N_{SYM}}{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N_{SYM}}\quad\left( {{P_{I}^{2}(i)} + {P_{Q}^{2}(i)}} \right)}}},} & {{Eq}\quad(21)} \end{matrix}$ where P_(I) and P_(Q) are the inphase and quadrature filtered pilot symbols, and N_(SYM) is the number of symbols over which the energy is accumulated to provide the Es value. Referring to FIG. 7, the filtered pilot symbols can be generated by accumulating the despread samples over the length of the channelization code used to cover the pilot reference. The total noise can be estimated as the energy of the variations in the energy of the desired signal, which can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{Nt} = {\frac{1}{N_{SYM} - 1}{\left\{ {{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N_{SYM}}\quad\left( {{P_{I}^{2}(i)} + {P_{Q}^{2}(i)}} \right)} - {\frac{1}{N_{SYM}}\left( {\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N_{SYM}}\quad{P_{I}(i)}} \right)^{2}} - {\frac{1}{N_{SYM}}\left( {\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{N_{SYM}}\quad{P_{Q}(i)}} \right)^{2}}} \right\}.}}} & {{Eq}\quad(22)} \end{matrix}$ The measurement of the received signal quality is described in further detail in U.S. Pat. No. 5,903,554, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MEASURING LINK QUALITY IN A SPREAD SPECTRUM COMMUNICATION SYSTEM,” and U.S. Pat. No. 5,799,005, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR DETERMINING RECEIVED PILOT POWER AND PATH LOSS IN A CDMA COMMUNICATION SYSTEM,” both assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated herein by reference.

For the signal processing path that includes equalizer 310, the signal quality can be estimated using various criteria, including a mean square error (MSE). Again, for CDMA systems that transmit TDM pilot reference, the MSE can be estimated during the pilot reference period, and can be computed as: $\begin{matrix} {{{MSE} = {\frac{1}{N_{SAM}}{\sum\limits_{n = 1}^{N_{SAM}}\quad{{{y(n)} - {\hat{y}(n)}}}^{2}}}},} & {{{Eq}\quad(23)}\quad} \end{matrix}$ where N_(SAM) is the number of samples over which the error is accumulated to provide the MSE. Typically, the mean square error is averaged over a number of samples, and over one or more pilot references, to obtain a desired level of confidence in the measurement. The mean square error can then be translated to an equivalent signal-to-noise ratio, which can be expressed as: $\begin{matrix} {{S\text{/}N_{EQ}} = {{\frac{1}{MSE} - {1\quad{linear}}}\quad = {10\quad{\log\left( {\frac{1}{MSE} - 1} \right)}{{dB}.}}}} & {{Eq}\quad(24)} \end{matrix}$

The S/N_(EQ) for the signal processing path with equalizer 310 can be compared with the S/N_(RAKE) for the signal processing path with rake receiver 330. The signal processing path that provides the better S/N can then be selected to process the received signals.

Alternatively, the MSE can be computed for the signal processing path with rake receiver 330 (using equation 23) and compared against the MSE computed for the signal processing path with equalizer 310. The signal processing path with the better MSE can then be selected.

For the HDR system, the S/N is estimated at a remote terminal and used to determine a maximum data rate that can be received by the remote terminal for the operating conditions. The maximum data rate is then transmitted back to the base station for which the S/N is estimated. Thereafter, that base station transmits to the remote terminal at a data rate up to identified maximum data rate.

With the present invention, the data rate for a data transmission can be estimated using various methods. In one method, the S/N can be estimated for the rake receiver or for the equalizer based on the computed MSE, as shown in equation (24). The best S/N from all signal processing paths can then be used to determine a maximum data rate that can be supported. Alternatively, the MSE can be used to directly determine the maximum data rate. The best S/N, MSE, or maximum data rate can be sent to the base station.

Under certain operating conditions, the signal processing path with the equalizer can provide better performance than the one with the rake receiver. For example, the signal processing path with the equalizer typically performs better when the S/N is high and for channels with ISI. The rake receiver can be used to process multipaths, which also cause ISI. In fact, the rake receiver can be viewed as a filter with L taps (where L corresponds to the number of finger processors), with each tap corresponding to a time delay that can be adjusted. However, the rake receiver is not as effective at reducing ISI due to frequency distortion in the received signals.

The equalizer can more effectively reduce ISI due to frequency distortion. This is achieved by providing a response that is approximately the inverse of the frequency distortion while attempting to minimize the overall noise, which includes the ISI. The equalizer thus “inverts” the channel and also attempts to smooth out the effect of multipath. In fact, each filter 410, when the coefficients are initialized to {0, . . . , 0, 1, 0, . . . , 0}, is equivalent to one finger processor. Subsequently, as the zero-valued coefficients are adapted, the filter frequency response is altered to equalize the channel distortion. Thus, the equalizer can be used to effectively deal with both multipath-induced ISI and channel-induced ISI.

For simplicity, many of the aspects and embodiments of the invention have been described for a spread spectrum communication system. However, many of the principles of the invention described herein can be applied to non-spread spectrum communication systems, and communication systems capable of selectively performing direct sequence spreading, such as the HDR system.

Filters 410 in FIGS. 4A and 4B can be designed to be of any length (i.e., any number of taps and coefficients). More taps allow filter 410 to better correct for frequency distortion in the received signal and to process multipaths having larger time offsets. However, more taps equate to increased complexity, more complicated computations to equalize the taps, and possibly longer convergence time. The number of taps is thus a design choice and is selected based on a number of factors including, for example, costs, performance, complexity, and so on. For example, it may be desirable to provide equalization over a particular time window (e.g., 20 μsec), in which case the number of taps may be dependent on the sample rate, f_(SAMP). Any number of taps can be employed and are within the scope of the invention.

The processing units described herein (e.g., filters 410, equalizer 310, post processor 320, rake receiver 330, and so on) can be implemented in various manners such as, for example, within one or more application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), digital signal processors (DSPs), microcontrollers, microprocessors, or other electronic circuits designed to perform the functions described herein. Also, the processing units can be implemented with a general-purpose or specially designed processor operated to execute instruction codes that implement the functions described herein. Thus, the processing units described herein can be implemented using hardware, software, or a combination thereof.

The foregoing description of the preferred embodiments is provided to enable any person skilled in the art to make or use the present invention. Various modifications to these embodiments will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art, and the generic principles defined herein may be applied to other embodiments without the use of the inventive faculty. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the embodiments shown herein but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the principles and novel features disclosed herein. 

1. An apparatus comprising: an equalizer configured to process signal samples to provide symbol estimates, the equalizer comprising a filter and a coefficient adjustment element, the coefficient adjustment element being configured to adjust coefficients used by the filter to filter the signal samples; a despreader configured to despread the symbol estimates from the equalizer to generate despread symbols; a decover element configured to decover the despread symbols to generate a first stream of recovered symbols; a rake receiver configured to process one or more multipaths of the signal samples to provide a second stream of recovered symbols; a controller configured to estimate a first signal quality of the first stream of recovered symbols and a second signal quality of the second stream of recovered symbols, the controller comparing the first and second signal qualities; and a switch configured to select the equalizer or the rake receiver to generate recovered data symbols.
 2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the equalizer and rake receiver both operate on pilot samples, then based on the first and second signal qualities estimated by the controller, the switch selects either the rake receiver or the equalizer to process data samples.
 3. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the despreader and decover element are configured to selectively despread and decover depending on a data rate of a received signal associated with the signal samples.
 4. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the controller is configured to estimate the first signal quality of the first stream of recovered symbols with a mean square error (MSE) between the symbol estimates and expected symbols.
 5. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the equalizer is configured to use information from the rake receiver.
 6. The apparatus of claim 5, wherein the rake receiver is configured to identify a strongest multipath of the signal samples, the coefficient adjustment element being configured to adjust the coefficients according to information related to the identified strongest multipath.
 7. The apparatus of claim 6, wherein the information comprises a time offset of the identified strongest multipath.
 8. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to minimize a mean square error (MSE) between the symbol estimates and expected symbols.
 9. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to minimize a mean square error (MSE) between filtered samples from the filter and expected symbols.
 10. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the filter comprises at least one of a finite impulse response (FIR) filter and an infinite impulse response (IIR) filter.
 11. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to use a received pilot signal and an expected pilot signal to adjust the coefficients.
 12. The apparatus of claim 11, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to use at least one of a time division multiplexed (TDM) pilot signal and a code division multiplexed (CDM) pilot signal.
 13. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to use at least one of a least mean square (LMS) algorithm, a recursive least square (RLS) algorithm, and a direct matrix inversion (DMI) algorithm.
 14. The apparatus of claim 1, further comprising a plurality of antennas configured to receive a signal, wherein the equalizer comprises a plurality of filters and a plurality of scaling elements, each filter being configured to filter samples of the signal received by a specific antenna, each scaling element being configured to scale filtered samples from a specific filter, the coefficient adjustment element being configured to provide scaling factors to the plurality of scaling elements.
 15. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the equalizer further comprises a summer configured to combine outputs from the plurality of scaling elements.
 16. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the rake receiver is configured to identify a strongest multipath of the signal samples, the coefficient adjustment element being configured to adjust the scaling factors based on the identified strongest multipath.
 17. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the coefficient adjustment element is configured to (a) adjust the coefficients with the one or more scaling factors fixed, and (b) adjust the scaling factors with the coefficients for one or more filters fixed.
 18. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the apparatus comprises a remote terminal.
 19. A system comprising: a base station configured to transmit a pilot signal and a data signal; a remote terminal configured to receive the pilot signal and data signal, the remote terminal comprising: an equalizer configured to process samples of the pilot and data signals to provide symbol estimates, the equalizer comprising a filter and a coefficient adjustment element, the coefficient adjustment element being configured to adjust coefficients used by the filter to filter the samples; a despreader configured to despread the symbol estimates from the equalizer to generate despread symbols; a decover element configured to decover the despread symbols to generate a first stream of recovered symbols; a rake receiver configured to process one or more multipaths of the pilot and data signals samples to provide a second stream of recovered symbols; a controller configured to estimate a first signal quality of the first stream of recovered symbols and a second signal quality of the second stream of recovered symbols, the controller comparing the first and second signal qualities; and a switch configured to select the equalizer or the rake receiver to generate recovered data symbols.
 20. The system of claim 19, wherein the remote terminal is configured to train the equalizer coefficients using the pilot signal and demodulate the data signal. 